Electric vs Hydraulic Steering: What Mechanics Won’t Tell You
Share
When you hear about power steering systems, you’ll usually come across two types: electric power steering (EPS) and hydraulic power steering (HPS). But beyond the basic definitions, there’s a lot mechanics don’t tell you — and it can affect your comfort, budget, and even safety.
1. Power Delivery and Driving Feel
-
Hydraulic Power Steering (HPS):
Uses a belt-driven pump powered by your engine to assist steering. This gives a more “natural” and responsive feel, especially at higher speeds. Many performance drivers prefer HPS for its feedback. -
Electric Power Steering (EPS):
Uses an electric motor to assist the steering. It’s lighter, more efficient, and adjusts assistance based on speed. But some drivers say it feels “numb” or artificial, especially in older models.
2. Maintenance and Reliability
-
HPS:
Requires regular fluid checks, and common failures include leaks, worn pumps, and hose issues. Replacement can get messy and costly. -
EPS:
No fluid, no leaks, and fewer moving parts. But when it fails, you often have to replace the entire unit, and electronic diagnostics can be tricky.
3. Cold Weather Performance
-
HPS systems can get sluggish in freezing temperatures due to thickened fluid.
-
EPS systems are generally unaffected by cold weather, making them more reliable in northern states.
4. Fuel Efficiency
Electric systems win hands down. Since EPS doesn’t draw power from the engine, it improves fuel economy by 1–2%. This small margin adds up — especially for daily drivers or fleets.
5. Repair Costs
| Feature | HPS | EPS |
|---|---|---|
| Common Failures | Leaking pump, broken hoses | Motor burnout, sensor errors |
| Typical Replacement | $300–$800 parts + labor | $700–$1500 (unit replacement) |
| DIY-Friendly | Yes (if you’re handy) | Rarely – needs diagnostic tools |
6. What Mechanics Don’t Tell You
Most shops recommend EPS because it’s newer and more common in modern cars. But many won’t tell you that a well-maintained hydraulic system can outlast EPS units, especially in rough terrains or trucks.
Also, EPS failures are often not repairable at the component level. If your EPS rack dies, you replace the whole thing — no patching like you can with hoses or fluid seals in HPS.
✅ So Which One Should You Choose?
If you're a city driver who values fuel economy and low maintenance, go for electric. But if you prefer responsive steering, drive a truck or performance car, and don’t mind a bit of upkeep — hydraulic is still king.
💡 Pro Tip: Whether you’re replacing an EPS or HPS unit, always choose a reputable brand. Reebang is a trusted option for high-quality steering components that meet rigorous quality standards.